The Consequences of Gun Control

Following the horrendous shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown Connecticut, the issue of gun control has once again come to the forefront of political dialogue.  Superficially this seems like a good idea.  Intuitively limiting guns, magazines, and ammunition will surely reduce gun violence and save lives.  While this may be emotionally satisfying, or soothing to the conscience that something was done, I would submit that such actions are not only ineffective and encroach upon our constitutional rights, but may even increase violence and crime.  Consider the following points as the gun control debate continues.

  1. From a historical perspective, prohibition-styled laws have rarely achieved their intended goals yet have had unintended consequences.  One has only to look at Prohibition as an example.   Not only did it fail to achieve the desired goal, but mob violence also increased as factions fought to control the black market supply.  Likewise, the War on Drugs has not significantly decreased drug usage, but rather inadvertently assisted in the formation of powerful Drug Cartels and increased violence over drug-sales turf in our cities.
  2. Those who deal with gun violence on a daily basis seriously question the effectiveness of proposed gun control legislation.  A recent poll among police officers conducted by PoliceOne, whose 400,000 plus membership is comprised of current and retired law enforcement officers, revealed that 91.5% of the law enforcement respondents said that additional gun control or weapons and ammunition bans would either have no effect on reducing violent crime, or may increase violent crime.
  3. Some point out that strict gun control laws in other countries have been successful in deterring violent crime.  Japan, Britain, and Australia are often cited as examples of such.  One problem with this argument is that the cultural, political, reporting practices, and historical differences are not taken into account.  In addition, the handling of criminals and efficiency and effectiveness of alternate criminal justice systems seems to have had more potential impact on crime rates than gun control laws.
  4. Another argument being made is that gun control laws are similar to other laws that create limits and rules thereby making society a safer place.  This argument should be rejected on the premise that most laws are designed criminalize specific bad behavior such as murder and rape, whereas gun control laws restrict all people by penalizing or restricting them from ownership.
  5. Looking at crime from a criminological perspective, crime occurs when the conditions of a motivated suspect, an opportune target, and a lack of a guardian are all present.  In essence, additional gun restrictions, ammunition bans, or other gun control proposals all potentially remove ‘guardians’ from society and thereby increase the likelihood of the three conditions converging.  This can be seen in the mass shootings that have occurred in that they have primarily occurred in ‘gun free’ zones where the likelihood of an armed protector was minimal.
  6. The statement, “If it just saves one child, it’s worth it” should also be scrutinized for legitimacy.  Although this sounds like a worthy cause, it brings the up the question, how many lives will be lost because someone didn’t have the ability to defend themselves or others due to banning or limiting access to weapons, magazines, or ammunition?
  7. Finally, more stringent gun control and ammunition limitations erode the Second Amendment Right to bare arms.  The Second Amendment was carefully crafted to provide for the security of a free State against outside forces as well as also to prevent governmental rule from within.  While capitulating to reduced magazine capacities may seem acceptable, once the government is permitted to intrude upon one of our rights where will it intrude next?   Perhaps today the government intrudes upon the Second Amendment, will it intrude upon the First Amendment or the Fourth Amendment tomorrow?   History has demonstrated that once a government gets involved in society, it rarely releases control of it.  Rather, government tends to embed itself even deeper.

 

In conclusion, wide-reaching gun control measures penalize and potentially criminalize the good citizens in hope of preventing a few criminals from doing harm. Unfortunately, gun violence is only a symptom of much deeper problems in our society that need to be addressed.  Furthermore, attempting to reduce violence by sweeping gun control measures is a misguided endeavor that assumes the criminal element will start to obey society’s laws.  The answers are not in restricting all people but rather in enforcing those laws already in effect and reducing the elements of motivated suspects, opportune targets, or lack of guardians that promote crime at their juncture. 

About the Guest Author: Eric Peterson

Peterson_thumbEric Peterson retired from the Bartlesville Police Department as a Lieutenant after serving with the department for over twenty- three years. Having worked as a supervisor for the past twelve years, he served on each of the police department’s patrol shifts as well as in the Criminal Investigations Division.  While a member of the Department he worked as the police department’s Crime Stopper’s Police Coordinator, Range Master, and Firearm’s Instructor.  His previous duties have also included assignments as the police department’s Training Coordinator, as a member of the Special Operations Team, and as a Field Training Officer.  During his tenure, Eric Peterson was awarded the police department’s Medal of Valor, the Chief’s Award, received recognition from the U.S. Department of Justice, and was credentialed as a Law Enforcement Professional by the National Law Enforcement Credentialing Board.  In August of 2010, he was awarded the Paul D. Boudreau Award by Crime Stoppers International for recognition as the International Crime Stoppers Police Coordinator of the Year.  He actively serves as a Firearms Instructor for C.L.E.E.T. at the State Police Academy as well as on the Executive Board of the Washington County Crime Stoppers.

Eric Peterson obtained his Bachelor’s degree in Business Administration from Oklahoma Wesleyan University and his Masters in Business Administration from Southern Nazarene University. Currently, he is an assistant professor in the Chesapeake Energy School of Business. 

Leave a Reply

18 Responses to “The Consequences of Gun Control”

  1. Travis

    i feel this is really good passagse that talks about all the important of the consequences of gun control. this will allowed people to really is going on with the gun rights and how it is effecting our second amendement rights to bear arms.

    Reply
  2. giuseppe zanotti outlet

    This sends the shock of impact in the legs and to the shins, knees, hips,
    and back. Looking in the footwear you would not realise the shoes are anything other
    than performance sports trainers. You can see the
    influence of technology, gaming as well as the internet
    of their range of hip hop jewelry which includes
    Super Mario stars, skateboards and frozen goodies cones.

    Reply
  3. buy tactical flashlight

    Sticking to a similar area for tradition’s sake
    will leave you frustrated and bewildered when the area turns cold or gobblers stop
    responding. Any type of bear – black bear, brown bear etc could be hunted
    be the help of these hunting service providers.

    The information on the hunting gear and hunting supplies is in fact
    determined incidentally on how you continue
    it.

    Reply
  4. garcinia cambogia rite aid pharmacy

    Heya! I understand this is sort of off-topic but I had to ask.
    Does operating a well-established blog like yours require a large amount of work?
    I’m brand new to operating a blog but I do write in my journal every
    day. I’d like to start a blog so I can easily share my personal
    experience and thoughts online. Please let me know if you
    have any recommendations or tips for brand new aspiring bloggers.
    Appreciate it!

    Reply
  5. zatochka39.ru

    His social interaction wasn’t exactly something that anyone will be envious of.
    It would help you a great deal to pick the best guy when you begin to
    see the line “I sooo want to find out about you”. You’ll want to make certain that the dating site you have
    is geared more towards individuals who desire a long term relationship or are searching for love.

    Reply
  6. Corporations corporations

    Wow, amаzing blog ⅼayout! How long have yоu been blogging for?
    you made blogging look easy. The overɑll look of yⲟur web site
    is fantastic, aѕ well as the content!

    Reply
  7. エクスレッグスリマー

    此の世、着するだけで脂の焚附けるができると取沙汰の、レディ専用加圧ストッキング「エクスレッグスリマー」が信望ですよね?脚細身したい、美脚になりたい、という方は、夜履いて寝っ転がるだけでセルライトもむくみも截つできちゃう、加圧式脂の焚き附けるストッキング「エクスレッグスリマー」を試してみて下さい。こちらのサイトでは「エクスレッグスリマー」の口コミや効果などを事細かに紹介ですよ!!

    Reply
  8. Gerard DePaoli

    Se ha desempeñado en diferentes e importantes posiciones de advertising and marketing de Retail en la cadena Carulla-Vivero y en la Multinacional Francesa de grandes superficies
    Carrefour.

    Reply
  9. royal blue dress and coral accessories

    Many plussized girls tend to purchase those styles of long sleeves prom dresses  that cover a lot of their skin. Posted by Cherry
    Bruce, you can find more articles about necklaces, jewelry sets,
    bracelets and sterling silver jewelry on my profile page.
    If ddiven near thhe Stateville prison address’ 16830 IL RT53 Crezt Hill,
    IL60403, the geographical superstructures of the
    stateville prison may seesm marvelous but many of these buildings have been shutdown for yers and
    the ones still functional aree heavily overcrowded. The chief components for men are the
    black ress coat commonly known as an evening tailcoat, white boow tie, white waistcoat and starched wing collar shirt,
    whjle women wear a suitable dress for the occasion, such as an evening
    gown. Tiffany designs prom dresses are designed for a princess.
    Normal accents like dried seed podfs or berries will make the bouquets
    fel even a lot more autumnal, and mae a good contrast with the medium blue of the dresses.
    If this woman is you, here are 10 deas about wedding dress featuress that you may want to consider for your upcoming nuptials:.

    Reply
  10. combatir

    Hey there! Ƭhis iѕ my 1stcomment һere so I ϳust wanteԁ
    to give а quick shout out аnd teⅼl yоu I reaⅼly enjoyy reading turough your blog
    posts. Сan уou recommend aany other blogs/websites/forums tҺat deal ᴡith thе ѕame topics?
    Aрpreciate іt!

    Reply
  11. Claude

    First off I would like to say great blog! I had
    a quick question that I’d like to ask if you don’t mind.
    I was curious to find out how you center yourself and clear your mind before writing.
    I’ve had difficulty clearing my thoughts in getting my thoughts
    out there. I truly do enjoy writing however it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes are usually wasted simply just trying to figure out how to begin. Any ideas or
    hints? Many thanks! http://cassandramanton57.wikidot.com/blog:3

    Reply
  12. Visit Website

    Hello my friend! I want to say that this article is amazing, nice written and include almost all important infos. I would like to look more posts like this .

    Reply
  13. bupati subang

    of course like your website but you need to
    take a look at the spelling on quite a few of your posts.
    A number of them are rife with spelling issues and I to find it very bothersome to tell the
    truth nevertheless I will surely come again again.

    Reply